CLICK HERE FOR BLOGGER TEMPLATES AND MYSPACE LAYOUTS »

วันอังคารที่ 20 ตุลาคม พ.ศ. 2552

MEDIA INSTITUTION: MANUFACTURING CONSENT




Media is a mediator, on the one hand, media is a communication channels such as newspapers, magazines, television, radio, billboards, telephone, fax, and internet. Media is used to broadcast or narrowcast messages or information to audiences. In addition, media texts are produced by media institutions (media institution is an established, often profit-based organization, which deals in the creation and distribution of advertising, entertainment and information services.) mostly in order to make money because the media owners do not care about the audiences-economy or education, they just want to sell the number of audiences to their sponsors. Due to media is very close to every class of people and easy to consume; therefore, media absolutely affect people in terms of understanding, belief, and life style so media are often used by a group of people to manufacture consent.   

Manufacturing consent

When we are talking about manufacturing consent, the name of Chomsky usually pops up in our brains. Chomsky and his colleagues, Edward S. Herman tried to infer that in countries where the levers of power are in the hands of a state bureaucracy, media are used by the government and group of elite dominants in the field of propaganda. There are statements from Chomsky indicate propaganda in the public mind. The following statements indicate that people are convinced to follow whatever the institutions direct:

Anyone who has had any dealings with children knows that they're curious and creative. They want to explore things and figure out what's happening. A good bit of schooling is an effort to drive this out of them and to fit them into a mold, make them behave, stop thinking, not cause any trouble. It goes right from kindergarten up ... People are supposed to be obedient producers, do what they're told, and the rest of your life is supposed to be passive consuming. Don't think about things. Don't know about things ... Just do what you're told, pay attention to something else and maximize your consumption. That's the role of the public. (p.19)

People not only receive the custom, tradition practices and belief from school or academic institutions but also media. Media play an important role to convince or brainwash people who consume the media. Due to rich or powerful people own or occupy media therefore the media are used to manufacture their consent. For example, the KFC Corporation has faced with a problem of its chicken. The KFC was accused about using meat from a genetically engineered mutant bird-like creature or the method of slaughter but many people would not know that much because the media did not pay intention to present this issues or there must be something else that make this not interesting, maybe money? Therefore, the KFC still has its consent to feed the chicken in the same way.  




On the one hand, the rich or powerful people manufacture their consent through media according to the propaganda mode of Chomsky and Herman for example:

The magnitude of the public-information operations of large government and corporate bureaucracies that constitute the primary news sources is vast and ensures special access to the media. The Pentagon, for example, has a public-information service that involves many thousands of employees, spending hundreds of millions of dollars every year and dwarfing not only the public-information resources of any dissenting individual or group but the aggregate of such groups. In 1979 and 1980, during a brief interlude of relative openness (since closed down), the U.S. Air Force revealed that its public-information outreach included the following:

140 newspapers, 690,000 copies per week Airman magazine, monthly circulation 125,000 34 radio and I7 TV stations, primarily overseas 45,000 headquarters and unit news releases 615,000 hometown news releases 6,600 interviews with news media 3,200 news conferences 500 news media orientation flights 50 meetings with editorial boards 11,000 speeches

This excludes vast areas of the air force's public-information effort. Writing back in 1970, Senator J. W. Fulbright had found that the air force public-relations effort in 1968 involved 1,305 full-time employees, exclusive of additional thousands that "have public functions collateral to other duties." The air force at that time offered a weekly film-clip service for TV and a taped features program for use three times a week, sent to 1,139 radio stations; it also produced I48 motion pictures, of which 24 were released for public consumption. There is no reason to believe that the air force public-relations effort has diminished since the 1960s. (Chomsky & Herman, 1988)

This example shows only one branch, Air force and there are the other three branches. The Pentagon control significant media such as radio and television so the information of these sources usually are the same way for the main issues so the government can maintain their consent through the media as usual because they have more power.    


The reason why the rich or powerful people have to manufacture their consent is benefits. The reason of invading Iraq on March 20, 2003 from the United States and the United Kingdom is the President Saddam Hussein harbor and support Al-Qaeda including the Iraq government abuse human right but on August 30, 2005 the former President George W. Bush answered the antiwar protesters that the reason to continue fighting in Iraq is for protection of the country’ vast oil fields and preservation of the dollar as the world’s reserve currency. Even though this issue was widely criticized but another new issues are produced by the media under the government replaced this negative issue in a short time. Therefore, the US government benefit from the people ignorance.         

Chomsky has argued that the people in a society can be divided into two different classes: the top 20 per cent and the remaining 80 per cent. The top 20 per cent of the whole population is called as a professional class; this group of people has good education and they are more or less participate the government policies such as judges, lawyers, company manager, teacher, engineer, doctors, and intellectuals. The remaining 80 per cent is a working class. They are less interested in politics as long as they have enough money to support their satisfaction. According to Chomsky, the top 20 per cent is the group with money and power; therefore, as a social institution, media is classified as part of the 20 % of the professional class according to Chomsky’s proposition because the rich people only own media and people who working for such media usually are well-educated as well.

I have now talked about the definition of media, media institution, and the role of media in manufacturing consent including the propaganda model according to the work of Chomsky and Herman then the media classification. Now I would like to come up with how the media, as a one institution, work together with other institution in order to make a change in a society and political.  
The United States of America in 2008, Democratic presidential nominee Barack Obama has defeated Senator John McCain from Republican in the presidential election and he has become the American’s 44th president. What is a key success of this election?

The President Obama has used social media such as MySpace, Twitter, LinkedIn, Facebook etc. during 2007 in order to canvass and this presidential campaign was work. The other media such as television programs and radio responded this modern strategy. Actually the Obama’s team has created and worked together to show the Obama’s charismatic. Moreover, Obama used the media in terms of marketing purposes and regular people who were thinking that they were too far from the presidential candidate have changed their attitudes. Therefore, this issue was wide-spread overwhelmingly and all media were also spread news until the end he won this election. According to this case study, it is absolutely that the President Barack Obama has received many benefits from using social media as a mediator among himself and other people.  

Media is just like a coin which has two sides. People who own the media can use it for their own benefit (manufacturing consent) or for social benefits. However, we as the audiences have to consider and choose what messages or information are believable, trustable, and beneficial for avoiding being a victim of the interest person or group of people.     





1,376 words


References
            Peter G. & Graham M. (2000). MEDIA INSTITUTIONS: Key areas and their implications for understanding media. London: Arnold, pp. 5-43. 

Edward, S. H. & Noam, C. (1988). Manufacturing Consent Manufacturing Consent: The Political Economy of the Mass MediaNew York: Pantheon Books.

Christopher, S. R. (2008). The Web 2.0 Case Study: Barack Obama's Use of Social Media (Online). Available http://rollyson.net/download/GHCJ/Web2.0_CaseStudy_Obama_Social_Media.pdf

 





วันอาทิตย์ที่ 18 ตุลาคม พ.ศ. 2552

INTRODUCTION & INFORM

This blog is a part of Media Study course at the National Institute of Development Administration, Bangkok, Thailand as a final examination project.


There are two (2) subjects in this blog which are IDEOLOGY and MEDIA INSTITUTION.


Every single words in these two subjects are produced by e-sources, book base on my best understanding.


Any comment from my mistake is accepted and allowed.


Thank you

วันเสาร์ที่ 17 ตุลาคม พ.ศ. 2552

IDEOLOGY

What is ideology?
Ideology is a set of beliefs, perspectives, or ideas for a group of people towards a particular issue which affect their life styles or decision making and so on, in other words, ideology is a set of beliefs, perspectives, or ideas that direct one’s actions.

At first, the term ‘ideology’ is coined by a French philosopher, Count Destutt de Tracy in 1700s in order to describe the positive meaning of new science of ideas and then Napoleon also used the word ‘ideology’ but he acquired it as a negative meaning. During that the time of Napoleon’s era, this term was used to refer falsehood or unrealistic things but he wanted the followers to believe those things are real. Since the 19th century which called as the age of ideology because there were so much of the thought of the time could be distinguished from that prevailing in the previous centuries by features that would now be called ideological (Cranston, 2005). And from the work of Karl Marx, who argued that social structure or class-based power can be divided into two classes: Bourgeoisie and Proletariat, the term ideology is used by the bourgeoisie as a tool to control the proletariat (the powerful take control the powerless in Neo Marxism). In addition, a Marxist philosopher, Louis Pierre Althusser (1969) identified the three levels from his ‘theoretical practice’ and science work: economic level, the political level and the ideological level which clarifies that the ideological level generates the superstructure and it means that the dominant(s) taking control of the working class as well.    
According to the aforementioned statements, ideology in general is used by the dominant as a tool to control the lower class. This tool is a key to govern a society because the society should have the same belief in order to show their harmony. Ideology guides people how to live their lives or what are appropriate behaviors via symbols, words or media. There are many kinds of ideology in the field of communication, so this term is used in many ways nowadays such as politics, social science, and business including media. Due to the diversity of the term ‘ideology’; therefore, one can has many ideologies depends on what issue or situation that one concerns about. However, a community still has a main ideology to share their common belief with each other such as religions. 



Christian 

 

The picture of Mary Magdalene and Jesus Christ are used as sanctity of Christianity in a Christian society in order to persuade all Christians by the same belief. This ideology exists to guide the Christian how to live and love the other. 

Islamic or Muslim


The Qur’an is a book which consists of guidance and direction in Arabic and Maulid Nabi Muhammad is the prophet of Muslim. All Islamite share this belief and follow all the directions from the Qur’an such as a tradition of praying performance for five times a day.  

Buddhism 



All Buddhist respect the Buddha image, which represents the Lord Buddha and follow his disciples such as the five percepts in order to live together peacefully

However, religions usually represent good things or guide people to live their lives appropriately but some ideologies guide or persuade people to follow according to the dominant’s favorite. For instance, politicians persuade a community to believe that it is a good thing to have embankment near their lands so the politicians could make some profits from the embankment construction.  

The ideology usually classifies people into two classes. Gender ideology, for example, refers to attitudes regarding the appropriate roles, rights, and responsibilities of women and men in society (Kroska, 2006). Gender ideology consists of images, concepts and assumptions (Patai & Koertge, 1994). The gender ideology distinguishes people by physical or appearance into two groups: feminine and masculine. Therefore, gender ideology absolutely affects people appropriate behaviors in the society regarding gender.

This ideology comes from a fact that men are stronger than women and the belief that husband has more right and responsibility than wife. This belief exists until now and it affects women lives about crimes and also an organizational management due to gender discrimination. According to Naff (1994), therefore, argues that during the 1980s, the term "glass ceiling" was coined to describe the subtle barriers that block the advancement of women (and minorities) in organizational management field. The research studied the U.S. Merit Systems Protection Board (MSPB), from the questions that is the poor representation of women in senior level jobs a result of fewer qualified women, less ambition on the part of women, or have women indeed faced discriminatory treatment?, for example, and this study indicated that a glass ceiling does exist in the federal government.     

Another example from an article “Gender discrimination” of enots encyclopedia that is:
…sexual harassment has been the centerpiece of numerous court cases and legal decisions that have established government standards regarding harassment. In 1998, the U.S. Supreme Court made two important rulings that have had a significant effect on harassment claims. In Burlington Industries, Inc. v. Ellerth, the court ruled that, even if an employee did not report incidents of alleged harassment right when they occurred, the company was still liable for the behavior of the employee who committed the sexual acts. In Faragher v. City of Boca Raton, the court held that an employer could be held liable for harassment if a supervisor made threats regarding punishment if an employee did not have sex with him, even if those threats were never carried out. Together, the two decisions made it clear that the court holds companies strictly liable for actions carried out by supervisors who have direct authority over the person they are harassing, if the supervisor can alter the victim's employment status through hiring, firing, refusal to promote, etc…

Therefore, all of the above consequences may come from media which reproduce and present the gender ideology several times. A male president of well-known company gave a television interview describing that he is an ironhanded and strict person. He runs his business with a male executives and the company’s turnover or business profit was going very well for instance. Another example is from when the debating among John McCain and Barack Obama in 2008, all media present both of them characteristics, backgrounds, and contributions over and over again in order to indicate how good they are. In contrast, a woman become a problem and makes the male leader look negative immediately no matter whether how good she is for her work, in case of a scandal of Mr. Bill Clinton and Ms. Monica Lewinsky for example and the media tried to expose this issue for months. In addition, movies also reproduce the qualifications and duties of women as a weaker sex.

In short, ideology distinguishes people into the strong side and weak side in a society, on the other hand, ideology is an important tool to control a society and media significantly play a role of information or belief distribution. People usually defer whatever the media impose to them such as news presentation, television or radio interview, movies and so on. Therefore, ideology has both advantage and disadvantage for civil governance in the same time. 






1,203 words

   




References
 Crossley, N. (2005). Key Concepts in Critical Social Theory. London: Sage. pp. 113-117, 147-156.
Kroska, A. and Elman, C. (2006). Gender Ideology Discrepancies: Exploring a Control Model of Gender Ideology Change. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Sociological Association, Montreal Convention Center, Montreal, Quebec, Canada available http://www.allacademic.com/meta/p105145_index.html
Morash, M. (2006). Understanding gender, crime, and justice. California. Sage publication.
 Katherine, C. N.(1994). Through the Glass Ceiling: Prospects for the Advancement of Women in the Federal Civil Service. Public Administration Review, Vol. 54